In a Times article, Wu reveals that she was approached by producers that suggested changing the script into having Caucasian characters or making the film about a heterosexual couple. She cleverly declined those offers which would have made the film gear towards mainstream media. This independent film is a great example of how successful and relatable alternative media can be. By sticking with her original ideas for the script, she made the experience completely genuine and believable. As a heterosexual Asian woman watching the film, I was still able to relate to the main character's hardships of family approval and acceptance. Wu's cinematic choices as the auteur and author flawlessly portrayed the Asian culture and the delicate relationships between all the characters.
Debra Zimmerman and Catherine Saalfield's Author/Auteur: Feminist Literary Theory and Feminist Film touches on the subject of mother/daughter relationships. Alice Wu's Saving Face has a very genuine depiction of this type of relationship. Wu does stick to the stereotypical dictatorship-like mother/daughter relationship. Instead, she makes the character of Ma vulnerable as well. The movie takes you on a journey of healing in which both Wilhelmina and Ma aid each other's emotional wounds. Yes, it sounds sappy but trust me, Wu does an exceptional job of making the experience so realistic.
The most common critique that Alice Wu has received is her bold decision to create a film that disputes such significant factors in our society-sexual orientation, race, and gender. While some may admire her gutsy debut film, others such as film critic Eric Snider degrade her film as "only a slight variation on a theme we've seen much of in recent films, that of the gay person who comes out of the closet in a strict conservative environment." Critics aside, this film was received very well by the general audience. In the Saving Face reunion screening, Wu speaks of audience members of different ethnicities and ages that express to her how they were able to relate to the film.
More specifically, there is no doubt that this film provided a powerful voice for the gay community and for the Asian community as well. As a young Asian woman myself who occasionally struggles with the traditional ties of my culture, I saw myself in this film. The positive audience reaction has every bit to do with Wu's position as both the director and screenwriter. I think that if she had only fulfilled one of those roles, the film would not have been as successful as it was. This only stresses the importance of not only the prep work of writing the script but also the execution of it which Wu so brilliantly performed.
Alice Wu on "Saving Face"
"Saving Face" Cast Reunion
Saving Face directed by Alice Wu
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/05/29/movies/29leib.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 (New York Times article on Saving Face)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Qm0hAtCBP8 (Alice Wu on Saving Face)
http://www.ericdsnider.com/movies/saving-face/ (Eric Snider's Critique)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xsxXbnphz-4 (Saving Face Cast Reunion)
Bell Hooks, Introduction Reel to Real
Debra Zimmerman and Catherine Saalfield, Author/Auteur: Feminist Literary Theory and Feminist Film
No comments:
Post a Comment